Quail, and other notes

  1. Provision and Judgment in the Wilderness: Quail, Manna, and the Spirit

Exodus 16 & Numbers 11

We get quail twice, and they’re drastically different in tone.

Exodus 16: Quail is gracious provision. The people grumble after Marah (Ex. 15), but God answers with food—quail at evening, manna in the morning. It’s God meeting physical needs while teaching daily dependence.

Numbers 11: Nearly identical event, but here the people are rejecting manna, the “bread of heaven,” in favor of meat. This time, quail is a judgment: God gives them what they crave “until it comes out of their nostrils” (v. 20). While they’re chewing, a plague hits. The location gets named Kibroth-hattaavah, or graves of craving. Yikes.

This tells you: same provision, different response, different result. It’s not just about food, it’s about posture. Craving vs. trust. Flesh vs. Spirit.

Numbers 11:29 — Moses’ Wish for the Spirit

Beautiful moment. The Spirit comes on the 70 elders; they prophesy, and Moses says:

“Would that all the Lord’s people were prophets, and that the Lord would put his Spirit on them!”

That’s a deep foreshadowing of Pentecost, when the Spirit is poured on all God’s people. It shows Moses sees that leadership empowered by God’s Spirit—not just bread and quail—is the real sustenance of the people. It prefigures Joel 2 / Acts 2.


2. Jesus as the True Bread and True Provision

John 6:22–35 – Manna Connection

The people want another miracle. Jesus had just fed them with literal bread (John 6:1–14), so they bring up the OG miracle food—manna.
Jesus tells them flat-out: Moses didn’t give you that bread; God did. But the real bread isn’t manna. It’s me.

“I am the bread of life. Whoever comes to me shall not hunger…” (John 6:35)

This is huge:

He’s greater than Moses (Hebrews 3).

He is what manna pointed to: God’s presence in daily dependence.

Their doubt about provision echoes Moses’ own doubts in Numbers 11:13—“Where am I to get meat for all these people?”

But where Moses faltered, Jesus provides.


3. Water Imagery: Eden, Spirit, Judgment, and Life

John 7:37–39 – Water of Life

“If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink. Whoever believes in me, as the Scripture has said, ‘Out of his heart will flow rivers of living water.’”

John editorializes: this is about the Spirit, yet to be given. Now buckle up, ‘cause this connects everywhere:

Eden (Genesis 2): Four rivers flow from the garden—symbol of life, presence, abundance.

Exodus 15:25: Bitter waters made sweet by a tree. The wood brings life—tree becomes a symbol of transformation (cross?).

Exodus 17 / Numbers 20: Moses strikes the rock → water flows. 1 Corinthians 10:4: That rock was Christ. He was struck once, and water (Spirit, life) flows.

John 19:34: Water and blood flow from Jesus’ side. Temple imagery, sacrificial imagery, new creation imagery.

We’re seeing a unified theme: life-giving water from God’s provision, especially when something is struck, offered, or judged.


4. Waters of Judgment and Testing

Exodus 32:20 — Golden Calf

Moses grinds the idol to powder, throws it into water, and makes the people drink it. It’s not just nasty—it’s a form of judgment, like the trial by ordeal referenced in…

Numbers 5:18–31 — The Waters of Bitterness

The adulterous woman must drink water mixed with dust and curses. If she’s guilty, her belly swells and she’s cursed. If innocent, she’s vindicated.

This is crucial: water can mean life or death, blessing or curse. And Jesus offers living water and he drinks the cup of bitterness on our behalf (cf. Gethsemane, Luke 22:42–44). Jesus is innocent, drinking on behalf of an adulterous people.


5. Tree of Life, Jesse, and New Creation

Romans 15:12 / Isaiah 11:1–11

“The Root of Jesse will come, even he who arises to rule the Gentiles…”

That “shoot” is Jesus. A new beginning from David’s line. Then you tie it to…

Revelation 21:9–22:5

The tree of life appears again—this time in New Jerusalem, planted by the river of life, bearing fruit for the healing of the nations. No more curse. Eden restored.

John as New Creation Book?

Yep. John opens with:

“In the beginning was the Word…” (John 1:1)
Mirroring Genesis 1.

John ends with the resurrection in a garden (John 20). The crucified gardener now restores Eden.


Synthesis

THEME OLD TESTAMENT NEW TESTAMENT FULFILLMENT

Bread Manna (Ex. 16) John 6: Jesus is bread Daily dependence on Christ
Meat/Quail Judged for craving (Num. 11) Flesh vs Spirit Craving flesh = spiritual death
Spirit Given to elders (Num. 11) John 7, Acts 2 Spirit for all believers
Water Eden rivers, bitter/sweet water, judgment waters John 4, 7, 19; 1 Cor 10 Jesus = living water; struck rock
Tree Eden, wood sweetens water, tree of life Cross, Rev 22 Cross = tree that brings life
Idolatry / Adultery Bitter water of judgment Cup Jesus drinks He takes our curse
Davidic Hope Shoot of Jesse Jesus reigns Tree of life reborn in new Eden

A Loaf of Shadows and Blood: A Sequel


Chapter 1: The Return of the Harvest

The bakery, now rebuilt and thriving, stood as a testament to survival in the small town. Its sourdough bread, crafted from the same recipe that had been passed down for generations, symbolized a return to normalcy. Ethan, Hannah, and their son Jonah had rebuilt their lives after the fire, but something lingered in the air—something that couldn’t be named. The town had become quieter. Crops had been poor that year, and the once-vibrant market now seemed to hum with an unspoken unease.

Hannah could feel it in her bones—the change in the land. The air was too still, the trees too silent. And every night, when the wind howled through the town, she thought she could hear whispers from the woods, calling her name.

It was on a foggy morning, when the town was still wrapped in the quiet of early winter, that Samuel Weaver arrived. He came from a neighboring town, one that had long been steeped in folklore and strange happenings. The locals there spoke in hushed tones about rituals and curses, but Samuel was different. He wasn’t a man of stories—he was a man of warning.

“I’ve heard of your family,” Samuel said to Ethan one morning, his voice low and urgent. “And I’ve heard of the curse that lingers in these woods.”


—

Chapter 2: The Weaver’s Warning

Samuel’s face was gaunt, his eyes hollow with something deep and unsettling. He spoke of the land—how it had been wronged, how the ritual they had performed to break the curse had been only a temporary fix. “The land is never truly free,” he explained, his voice thick with something ancient, something that seemed to seep from the ground itself. “The darkness that lives here, it feeds on regret. It feeds on fear.”

Hannah had felt that fear since they’d returned, but hearing Samuel speak it aloud made it real in a way that sent a chill down her spine.

Ethan frowned. “What do you want from us?”

“I want you to come with me,” Samuel said, his gaze unwavering. “There’s a place in the woods where the veil between this world and the next is thin. It’s a place where the old rituals still hold power. If we don’t complete what was started, the land will take more than just crops.”

Hannah looked at Ethan, her heart heavy. She wanted to dismiss Samuel, but the look in his eyes told her that this wasn’t a man who would be easily ignored.


—

Chapter 3: The Old Ways

Samuel led them to his farmhouse, a place that seemed untouched by time. The house was dark and cold, the air thick with an earthy, musty scent. Inside, the walls were covered with strange symbols, runes etched into the wood as though they had been there for centuries. There was an altar in the center of the room, surrounded by candles that flickered unnaturally, casting long, twisting shadows on the walls.

Violet, Samuel’s daughter, stood silently in the corner. Her pale eyes watched them with a strange intensity, and though she never spoke, Hannah felt her presence like a weight pressing down on her chest.

“We must complete the ritual,” Samuel said, his voice grave. “We need to offer a sacrifice to the land. The blood of the innocent. It must be done to bind the darkness.”

Hannah recoiled. “You can’t mean Violet. She’s just a child.”

Samuel’s expression hardened. “The land demands it. The blood must be spilled.”

Ethan’s jaw clenched. “No. We’re not sacrificing anyone.”

Samuel’s eyes flickered to the window, where the wind howled through the trees, and the shadows outside seemed to shift and sway in the dark. “You don’t understand. The land has already claimed its price. If we don’t do this, it will take everything.”


—

Chapter 4: The Harvest Moon

That night, as the full moon rose high in the sky, they gathered in the woods for the ritual. The air was thick with fog, the trees looming like dark sentinels. The ground beneath their feet seemed to pulse with an unnatural energy, and the wind, once a whisper, now howled through the branches like a living thing.

Samuel stood at the center of the clearing, his hands raised to the sky as he began to chant in a language that felt ancient, forgotten. The words twisted the air around them, making the hairs on the back of Hannah’s neck stand on end. Violet stood motionless beside him, her eyes closed, her face pale and serene, as though she were already part of the ritual.

Jonah, clutching Ethan’s hand, looked up at his father with wide, fearful eyes. “I don’t want to do this,” he whispered. “I don’t want to lose her.”

Ethan squeezed his son’s hand but said nothing. He couldn’t bring himself to lie. They had no choice. The land had already claimed its toll.

As the ritual continued, the ground beneath them trembled. The trees groaned and creaked, their branches twisting like fingers reaching for something just out of reach. The wind howled, and the shadows seemed to stretch and curl, moving as though they had a mind of their own.

And then, just as the final words of the chant were spoken, something shifted in the air. The shadows grew darker, thicker, and from the corner of the clearing, a figure emerged—a figure that seemed to be made of nothing but shadow, a dark, formless shape that moved with a purpose.

Jonah gasped. “It’s her… it’s Mama.”

But it wasn’t Maria. It was something worse, something that had taken her form, something that had been waiting for the right moment to return.


—

Chapter 5: The Offering

The figure, now fully formed, moved toward them. Its presence was suffocating, its eyes—if they could be called eyes—glowed with an eerie, unnatural light. It spoke in a voice that was not a voice, but a whisper that came from all directions at once.

“You cannot escape what you’ve done,” it hissed. “You cannot outrun your sins.”

Hannah’s heart pounded in her chest as the figure drew closer, its shadow stretching longer with every step. Samuel, undeterred, continued the chant, his voice growing louder, more frantic. He was trying to bind the creature, trying to force it back into the earth, but it was too late. The creature’s shadow wrapped around Violet, pulling her toward it.

“No!” Hannah screamed, rushing forward, but it was as if the air itself had turned to stone. She couldn’t move. She could only watch as Violet’s body went limp, her blood spilling onto the earth, her life extinguished in an instant.

And then, as the ritual reached its climax, the ground beneath them split open with a deafening crack. The creature, now fully formed, let out a terrible scream, a sound that seemed to shake the very trees.


—

Chapter 6: The Binding

The creature, though bound to the earth, did not vanish. Instead, it lingered in the shadows, a presence that could not be ignored. The land had been fed, but it was still hungry. The trees around them seemed to bend and twist, their branches reaching out like claws, and the wind carried with it a dark, oppressive weight.

Ethan and Hannah stood together, their arms around Jonah, watching as Samuel, broken and trembling, knelt before the altar. “It’s not over,” he whispered. “The land is still hungry. It will never stop.”

Hannah’s heart sank. The ritual had bound the darkness to the land, but it had also bound them to it. The creature was gone, but its shadow lingered, waiting for the next offering.

The bakery, once a symbol of hope, now felt like a prison. The shadows seemed deeper, the warmth of the hearth unable to chase away the cold that had settled in their bones.

Ethan and Hannah both began to notice something strange: the bakery’s social media presence, once a minor part of their business, had taken on a life of its own. The photos of their bread, their smiling faces, had started to attract an unusual following. But it wasn’t just the bread that drew attention—it was something darker. The comments on their posts were filled with cryptic, unsettling messages. “We’re watching you,” one would say. “The land remembers,” said another.

At first, they thought it was just random trolls, but the messages grew more frequent, more specific. The followers, who had once been just customers and friends, now seemed to know too much about them. They knew about the fire. They knew about Maria’s death. They knew things that only someone from the town would know.

And then, one day, the posts stopped. The account was deleted, but not by them. The land, it seemed, had found a new way to feed.


—

Chapter 7: The Price of Redemption

The town continued to wither, the crops failing year after year. The people, once full of life, now moved through the streets like ghosts, their faces hollow, their eyes distant. The land had taken its toll, and there was no escaping it.

Ethan and Hannah, though bound by the curse, held on to each other, finding solace in their love and in the small moments of peace they could carve out from the darkness. Jonah, too, had grown quiet, his once-vibrant spirit dimmed by the weight of the land’s hunger.

The bakery remained, though the shadows grew longer each day. The people came, but they did not linger. They came for bread, for warmth, but left quickly, as though the very air in the bakery was too heavy to bear.

And though they had survived the ritual, the land still whispered. The trees still groaned. The shadows waited, and the digital whispers of the past seemed to grow louder, echoing through the world they could no longer escape.

THE END

A Loaf of Shadows and Love

—

Chapter 1: Hearth and Home

Hannah had returned to her Amish hometown with a heart full of uncertainty. After years of living in the modern world, she’d felt drawn back to her roots, unsure if she could reconcile the life she’d left behind with the one she now lived.

The bakery, however, was a constant. It was a sanctuary where her father’s legendary sourdough recipe symbolized tradition, family, and community. She’d spent her days there since returning, helping him knead dough and serve customers, hoping to find her place again.

The bell above the door jingled as Ethan and his daughter, Lucy, walked in one December morning. Lucy’s wide eyes sparkled as she took in the warm, inviting space.

“Wow!” Lucy exclaimed. “It smells amazing in here!”

Hannah smiled, handing her a cinnamon roll. “First one’s on the house.”

Lucy took a bite, her face lighting up. “This is the best thing I’ve ever tasted!”

Ethan chuckled, his voice deep and warm. “You’re spoiling her already.”

Hannah grinned. “That’s what bakeries are for.”

Their banter was easy, but beneath Ethan’s charm, Hannah sensed a shadow of grief. She didn’t press, though; she knew better than anyone how the past could weigh on someone.

—

Chapter 2: The Fire

The bakery was packed with holiday shoppers when it happened. Smoke began curling from the back room, faint at first but quickly growing darker. Hannah was the first to notice.

“Ethan!” she called, her voice sharp with panic. “Something’s wrong!”

Ethan’s head snapped up, and he immediately grabbed Lucy, ushering her toward the door.

Hannah darted into the back room, her heart pounding. Flames licked the walls, consuming shelves of flour and supplies. She grabbed the family’s recipe book, her fingers blistering as she clutched the leather cover.

Suddenly, Ethan appeared behind her. “Hannah, you can’t stay here!”

“I have to save this!” she shouted, holding up the book.

Ethan didn’t hesitate. He pulled her away just as the fire roared to life, forcing them to escape.

Outside, they stood together, watching the bakery burn. Hannah clutched the scorched recipe book to her chest, her mind racing with questions. How had this happened?

Among the crowd, a boy stood silently, his pale face illuminated by the flames. His expression was unnervingly calm, his eyes locked on Ethan.

—

Chapter 3: A Haunted Boy

The boy introduced himself as Jonah the next morning, claiming he had no family. He lingered around the ruins of the bakery, his presence unsettling yet strangely compelling.

Ethan couldn’t shake the feeling he’d seen Jonah before. The boy’s cryptic comments only deepened the mystery.

“You can’t hide from what you’ve done,” Jonah said one evening, his voice steady and cold.

“What are you talking about?” Ethan demanded.

Jonah didn’t answer, but his gaze was heavy with accusation.

—

Chapter 4: Samuel’s Secret

Hannah sought answers from her father, Samuel. She found him in the barn, kneading dough with an intensity that betrayed his inner turmoil.

“Daed,” she said, holding out the recipe book she’d saved. “Do you think the fire was an accident?”

Samuel’s hands stilled. His eyes, usually calm and steady, flickered with unease.

“There are forces we don’t understand, Hannah,” he said, his voice low. “And sometimes, those forces find us through the choices we’ve made.”

“What do you mean?”

Samuel hesitated, then confessed. Years ago, he had secretly used social media to promote the bakery, despite the Amish community’s strict ban on technology. His posts had drawn attention—and jealousy. One disgruntled customer had cursed the bakery, claiming it was “tainted by modern sin.”

—

Chapter 5: Ethan’s Burden

Ethan’s sleepless nights were filled with memories of his late wife, Maria. She had died in a bakery fire years ago, trying to save their son—Jonah. Ethan had been too late to save them, and the guilt had consumed him ever since.

But now, faced with Jonah’s reappearance, Ethan realized the boy hadn’t died. Jonah had been taken by something dark, something vengeful.

—

Chapter 6: The Ritual of Sourdough

Samuel revealed an old Amish remedy for breaking curses: a ritual involving sourdough, the bread of life. The dough had to be infused with forgiveness and shared with the cursed soul to release it from its torment.

Hannah and Ethan worked late into the night in the ruins of the bakery, kneading the dough together. The act was more than just preparation; it became a catharsis for them both.

“Do you ever think about what you’d change if you could go back?” Ethan asked, his hands pressing into the dough.

“All the time,” Hannah admitted. “But I’m learning that regret doesn’t fix anything. It just keeps you stuck.”

Ethan nodded, his gaze fixed on the dough. “I’ve been stuck for a long time. Losing Maria and Jonah…I didn’t think I’d ever feel normal again. But being here, with you, it’s starting to feel like maybe I could.”

Hannah’s heart fluttered at his words. She met his eyes, and for the first time, she saw a glimmer of hope in them.


—

Chapter 7: The Confrontation

On Christmas Eve, the ritual was ready. The sourdough loaf, golden and fragrant, was infused with the essence of forgiveness through their shared effort. They found Jonah in the ruins of the bakery, his eyes glowing with an unnatural light, his presence chilling despite the winter air.

“Jonah,” Ethan said, stepping forward, his voice trembling but resolute. “I failed you and your mother. I wasn’t there when you needed me most. But I’m here now, and I won’t leave you again.”

Jonah’s glowing eyes flickered, uncertainty breaking through his anger.

Hannah stepped forward, holding the sourdough loaf. “This is for you,” she said softly, her voice steady despite her racing heart. “It’s made with forgiveness, Jonah. Let it help you find peace.”

Jonah hesitated, his expression wavering between rage and sorrow. Slowly, he reached out and took the loaf. He tore off a piece and ate it, his glowing eyes dimming with each bite.

As he finished, he collapsed into Ethan’s arms, sobbing. “I missed you, Dad,” he whispered.

Ethan held him tightly, tears streaming down his face. “I missed you too, Jonah. I’m so sorry.”


—

Chapter 8: A New Beginning

The bakery was rebuilt in the months that followed, a blend of old traditions and new beginnings. Ethan and Hannah worked together to create a space that honored her family’s heritage while incorporating Maria’s innovative marketing ideas.

Jonah, now free from the curse, lived with Ethan and Lucy, finally part of a family again. The boy had softened, his haunted demeanor replaced with the innocence of childhood.

On the bakery’s reopening day, Samuel approached Hannah, his eyes filled with both pride and regret.

“I’m sorry for the shadows my choices brought into your life,” he said.

Hannah hugged him tightly. “We’ve all made mistakes, Daed. What matters is how we move forward.”

That evening, as the first snow of the season fell, Ethan and Hannah stood outside the bakery, hand in hand, watching customers file in to enjoy the warmth and comfort of fresh bread.

“Do you think we’ve done enough?” Hannah asked, her breath visible in the frosty air.

Ethan smiled, squeezing her hand. “We’ve done more than enough. Together, we’ve made something new.”

The warm glow of the bakery’s lights spilled onto the snow, a symbol of redemption, love, and the power of second chances.

THE END

Horus and Christ: or, Some Notes on what the Warp, Hume and the Bible can Teach Us About Reasoning and Knowledge

Induction for Hume is rooted in the empirical nature of humans, and this empirical, material nature is one reason why reasoning is much more piecemeal than we suppose. This may be helpfully illustrated by elements of fascination in horror. Horror narratives often involve the characters stumbling around for clues, while discovery and disclosure come in staccato, unintentional bursts and uneven flashes of insight. Confirmation, hypothesis and even doubt all play a role in this piecemeal sort of reasoning, which is opposed to systemizing streams of data. To put a few fine points on it: reasoning here is practical, inductive, empirical, and material. It’s largely, as Hume also noted, matter of fact as opposed to necessary. Reasoning, proof, induction all happen because we are curious. Curiosity is an appetite of the mind and emerges from matter. Rationality is material and human. We are inclined to induction because of our material nature as rational and curious animals. Our status as rational animals entails the sociality of all of the above, reasoning, induction, and even logic itself. Rather than being the laws of reality, as it were, logic is simply the laws of human thought, and as human thought is inherently social (there is no private language, even in thought) logic is a social phenomenon. Quine was willing to grant that it was possible to revise the laws of logic. Causal reasoning rooted in historical, evolutionary biology. So both inductive and causal reasoning is rooted in material human nature.

Hume’s view of reasoning aligns with the piecemeal discovery often found in horror narratives because he emphasizes the inductive, empirical, and material nature of human thought. This means that our understanding of the world is built gradually through experiences and observations, rather than through pure deduction or innate ideas.

For Hume, “induction is rooted in the empirical nature of humans,” and this leads to a more fragmented and gradual process of discovery. Horror narratives often mirror this process by presenting characters who must piece together clues and insights in a nonlinear and often disorienting way. The characters in these stories rarely receive a complete and coherent explanation of the threats they face from the outset. Instead, they must grapple with uncertainty, ambiguity, and partial revelations as they struggle to survive.


This piecemeal approach to knowledge is further illustrated by the comparison to exploring the Warhammer 40k universe and the Bible. In both cases, understanding emerges through a process of accumulating knowledge and connecting disparate pieces of information.

Just as horror protagonists gradually uncover the true nature of the horror they confront, individuals engaging with these complex fictional worlds assemble a more comprehensive understanding through exploration and investigation. This approach to understanding resonates with Hume’s emphasis on inductive reasoning as a “matter of fact” process grounded in our experiences and observations. Curiosity, described as an “appetite of the mind,” motivates us to seek knowledge and connect information.

This inherent drive to understand the world around us pushes us to piece together fragments of information, just as characters in horror narratives are driven to uncover the truth behind the terrifying events they experience. Ultimately, Hume’s view of reasoning as a material, social, and inductive process aligns well with the gradual and often disorienting nature of discovery in horror narratives. Both emphasize the importance of experience, observation, and the interconnectedness of knowledge in shaping our understanding.

The “no-spoiler” nature of both the Warhammer 40K universe and the Bible both point to a concept of interconnected knowledge. What I mean by “no spoiler” is this: regardless of where one begins exploring in either, the journey ultimately leads to the same core understanding. In 40K, this destination is the Horus Heresy, a pivotal event shaping the universe’s trajectory. Similarly, exploring the Bible, regardless of the starting point, ultimately leads to a unified understanding of its central themes, the most central of which is Jesus (Luke 24). It doesn’t matter where one starts in either narrative, as each narrative is a matter of piecing together and arranging “revelations” as they are found. The very first thing one learns about 40K is what happens at the end of the Horus Heresy, with the most recent novels only just being released. The very first thing one learns about the Bible, or Christianity, is that Jesus died for your sins, which is the climax of Jesus’s earthly work.

This idea resonates with the concept of inductive reasoning discussed above. Inductive reasoning, as described by Hume, is a process of piecing together knowledge from experiences and observations.


Just as horror narratives often involve characters gradually uncovering clues and insights, leading to a complete picture, exploring 40K and the Bible involves accumulating knowledge that ultimately converges towards a central understanding. We are driven by curiosity, an “appetite of the mind,” to learn and connect information. Our reasoning is not purely abstract but grounded in our experiences and interactions with the world. The interconnectedness of knowledge in 40K and the Bible, where different paths lead to the same fundamental truths, suggests that knowledge itself might be inherently interconnected. This interconnectedness could be a reflection of the material and social nature of human reasoning, where we constantly seek to connect and synthesize information.

Addendum on Tongues

I see the line of reasoning that tongues ceased with the Apostles more and more as a defense of cessationism in general. Link tongues to revelation, which requires apostolic authority, so that it can go away with the apostles.

However, tongues are not revelatory in the same sense that Scripture is, because if they were then it would be written in Scripture with apostolic authority.


We know Scripture is revelation, and that apostolic authority stamps it as so. The revelation of Tongues, if they were revelatory in that same sense, would be written in Scripture, like prophecy is, stamped with apostolic authority. So I doubt that tongues are revelatory in the same sense as scripture that requires apostolic authority.

Jesus Is Not Eternally Begotten

Hebrews 5:5 seems to make this quite clear. In contrast to the Olympic level of mental gymnastics required to make the metaphysics of eternal-begottenism even so much as possible, Hebrews says that God begot the Son on a specific day. John tells us that the Word was with God, so the eternality of the Son isn’t in question, but Hebrews makes “Son” and “begotten” out to be functions, not metaphysical attributes. Begotten before all worlds? More like, before this specific world.

Rolling Right of the Tongue(s): or, a Few Thoughts on Arguments on Tongues Being Human Languages and Cessationism

download

 

 

On page 2,129 of the Reformation Study Bible (a fine study Bible) there’s a note on 1 Corinthians 12:10 that ends with: “There is no reason to conclude that the “tongues” of 1 Cor differ from the “tongues” of Acts 2”. This is possibly the worst note in this entire Bible. The first glaring reason we have for thinking it’s wrong: the tongues of Acts did not require an interpreter and were simply understood by the audience at Pentecost, since it was in their own language(s). The tongues of Corinthians require someone with the gift of interpreting tongues, something we see two chapters later in 1 Corinthians 14:

Continue reading →

No Spirit, No Salvation, or Salvation Apart from the Spirit?

The role of the Holy Spirit in salvation is well-attested in Scripture, as John Piper helpfully catalogs. He rightly says, ‘no Spirit, no Salvation’. There is however a curious little story in Acts (Acts is full of curious little stories) that jarred me a little bit when I first read it, because it seems to contradict, or at the very least complicate, the Spirits role in salvation:

 

‘And it happened, while Apollos was at Corinth, that Paul, having passed through the upper regions, came to Ephesus. And finding some disciples he said to them, “Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?” So they said to him, “We have not so much as heard whether there is a Holy Spirit.” And he said to them, “Into what then were you baptized?” So they said, “Into John’s baptism.” Then Paul said, “John indeed baptized with a baptism of repentance, saying to the people that they should believe on Him who would come after him, that is, on Christ Jesus.” When they heard this, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. 6 And when Paul had laid hands on them, the Holy Spirit came upon them, and they spoke with tongues and prophesied.  Now the men were about twelve in all.’ (Acts 19:1-7)

 

This is quite an interesting situation. It’s not referenced again in Scripture, and the tone doesn’t strike one as overly urgent. Paul doesn’t appear to question the disciples’ salvation, and he acknowledges that they have believed, nor does the Bible call them anything but ‘disciples’. Paul’s action isn’t to lead them to repent and believe the Gospel but to lay hands on them, whereupon the Spirit comes on them and they prophesy. The number of disciples mirrors the number of disciples at Pentecost, and both events resemble each other in that the end result of the Spirit coming upon them is tongues and prophecy. 

 

So what’s going on here? Clearly, there can’t be salvation wholly apart from the Spirit. John Piper is correct here. However, this passage does seem to lend credence to the Pentecostal idea of a ‘second filling of the holy spirit’ or a ‘second blessing’ , often mentioned in the context of a baptism of the Holy Spirit where tongues is seen as the evidence of a second filling (this is distinct from the Wesleyan doctrine of ‘second blessing’’). This is perhaps a topic for another time, though. 

 

At any rate, it’s clear that while there is no salvation apart from the Spirit, there appears to be a sense in which believers in Christ can be believers without even knowing that there is a Holy Spirit or without what might be called the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. It would even appear that knowledge of the Spirit isn’t necessary for the salvation of believers in the New Testament; this would make salvation even more monergistic in the sense that one can be saved and be counted a believer without any knowledge of key aspects of salvation, even continuing into the Christian life. Salvation is an act of God through and through, perhaps to an extent whether the believer knows it or not. Is there salvation apart from the Spirit? No. Does salvation require anything of us, even knowledge of the Holy Spirit, even continuing on into the disciples life? No. Salvation requires God and nothing else. God’s mighty act of salvation and continuing work of sanctification in the Christian life are contingent on God alone, and now what the believer does or doesn’t know.

Notes and Thoughts on the Pactum Salutis

A while ago Peter Leithart blogged on the Pactum Salutis, and I’ve been mulling jit over ever since. The Pactum Salutis (PS) doctrine turns on the idea of negotiated agreement or settlement or whatever term you prefer. The extent to which this is flattened and weakened is the extent to which the PS really stops being an actual doctrine of PS. Turretin and Owen (among others) try to turn the PS into a super duper trinitarian thing but also keep it super duper undivided by limiting the PS to the economy. Of course it pretty much isn’t ad intra at this point, and also at this point there really ceases to be any kind of ‘agreement’ between ‘legal parties’ as the PS posits. There isn’t much of a way to have your cake and eat it too here. Continue reading →